Super Tuesday happened yesterday. If you’re reading this right now, you’re either incredibly happy, angry, or just straight up confused. I fall into the 3rd category honestly. The moderate wing of the Democratic Party got their shit together and finally picked a moderate frontrunner whereas the progressive wing is still split.
I’m going to break down the case for and against Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders because I think some supporters aren’t able to look at the big picture of this race.
First up: Joe Biden.
Biden is a staple moderate candidate who has put together a coalition of older black voters, moderates, and suburban democrats. His campaign started off with a large lead over the other candidates and led into a dip as Sanders and Buttigieg gained more traction, but after both Buttigieg and Klobuchar dropped out and endorsed Biden, it gave him the momentum to win approximately 8 states. Biden’s policy stances are essentially very moderate in which he wants to build on the Affordable Care Act, lower college & health care costs, raise taxes on the wealthy, and fight for, as he calls it, “the soul of the country.” His argument of providing a moderate candidate to take on Trump is an argument that I agree with personally. Progressives who were angry the nomination went to Clinton over Sanders in 2016 are saying that since we already chose a moderate and lost, we need to pick an outsider, ie. Sanders. The issue with that argument is the fact that nominating Clinton was a horrible mistake because Clinton is absolutely crazy. Democrats lost in 2016 because Clinton ignored the swing states where we automated 4 million manufacturing jobs and Trump blamed it on the immigrants, which is a statement that white working class voters might not agree with but it’s better than being ignored by the Democratic Party. The 2016 election was a complete disaster, so we can’t use it to predict the 2020 election. Nominating a moderate in the 2020 election will provide a path for moderate republicans, democrats, and progressives, whereas nominating Sanders would force republicans (& and some democrats) to vote for Trump or not vote at all. Progressives are guaranteed to vote against Trump but moderates are not, so we have to pick a candidate that will appeal to all sides of the spectrum, especially those who are sick of Trump but don’t want the country to be led by a democratic socialist.
Joe’s message of wanting to unite the party is coming across very well, especially after we saw the GOP fall apart in 2016 after the party’s leadership failed to stop Trump from getting the nomination. The common chant of Biden supporters (“We Know Joe!”) is a small but simple message that rings true – we do know Joe and we’ve seen his record. He fought for the Affordable Care Act with Obama during a time where Congress was incredibly divided, he has incredible experience in Congress as a Senator, and he’s a lawyer. Biden actually overcame an incredible stutter (insanely impressive for a politician). Weeks after he was elected to the US Senate, his wife and daughter were killed in a car accident, and many years later his eldest son passed away as well. An unpublicized fact about Biden is that whenever he meets someone who’s suffered great personal loss, he gives them his personal cell phone number and says “If you feel low & have no place to turn, call me.” This is why people are drawn to Biden. They remember everything he and Obama did during the 2008 crisis and his record before that, and they trust him to become the president. I went to the rally in Dallas on Monday, and when you’re in the room, you can tell he has the trust of the people.
The issue with nominating Joe Biden however is that the man would do horrible in a debate against Trump. He has so many verbal mistakes that the things he says are just flat wrong sometimes. One time he even said he graduated with 3 degrees – I have literally no words for how he got to that conclusion, but this is what people are scared of. Also, beautifully put by The Daily, “Joe Biden is playing by a rulebook that was wrote in 1980.” He will be going up against Donald Trump who is incredibly narcissistic and unusual, but maybe the debates will just be the 2 of them trying to outdo each other with off color statements. Another issue with nominating Biden is the history of his son in Ukraine, which is something that Trump will bring up throughout the whole election – similar to Clinton in 2016. That all being said, the only time Democrats have won is when they nominate a moderate candidate, ie. Clinton & Obama that build a movement of hope and love – a notion that Biden has accomplished (& it’s working).
Next up: Bernie Sanders.
Bernie Sanders is known as the progressive democratic socialist who is pushing progressive bills in the Senate like Medicare for All, the Green New Deal, and College for All. Sanders’s history as a US House Representative and mayor of Burlington and the legislation he put forth show his tireless efforts to fight for the working class, which is the main message of his presidential campaign in both 2016 & 2020. The Sanders campaign has made incredible gains over the course of the year, specifically by winning the popular vote in New Hampshire & the caucuses in Iowa (probably) and Nevada. Going into Super Tuesday, Sanders was expected to sweep, but the sudden rally of the moderates gave Biden a majority in states like Texas – I think as of right now Sanders has won ~4 states & Biden ~8. Sanders has put together a coalition of Latinos, the youth, the working class, and progressives. His overall message of “Not Me, Us” shows that his campaign has truly turned into a progressive movement.
The demonstration of his humanity through his consistent activist record
- Ran for class president in high school to raise scholarship funds for Korean War orphans
- Arrested for protesting segregation in 1962
- Opposed both Iraq wars on moral grounds
- Attended the March on Washington with MLK Jr
- Was forcibly removed from protest about Willis Wagons in Chicago
And that’s just the tip of the iceberg for his activist record. Combined with his legislative record in the House where he was known as the “amendment king,” his record certainly shows that the man is passionate and determined. Bernie’s message is that he is done waiting for progressive action to slowly make its way through Congress and that he wants change right now – and there are a lot of people who agree with him. The argument to nominate Bernie mainly stems from if you have a crazy populist movement on the right, you can match it with a crazy populist movement on the left or fight with a moderate. Trump’s movement of white working class anger matched with minority working class anger would end in a brutal battle but it might work.
A big issue with Bernie is his policies. Many Democrats like the idea of where the progressive goals would end up, but they don’t support the methodology to get to those goals (I fall in this camp myself). The complete ban on fracking will not only make an incredibly difficult transition from fossil fuel to renewable, but in swing states like Pennsylvania (which Trump won in 2016 but Obama won previously) where fracking is a big part of their economy, it will have a severe impact during the general election. A similar hard transition will be his Medicare for All plan which would eliminate all private insurance, and although everyone wants everyone to have access to health care, a complete description of the system would essentially hand the entire election to Trump. Providing a public option and lowering health care costs overall – especially with the threat of coronavirus – provides a much more pragmatic and practical result (one that would actually get through Congress & win over moderates). The big problem with Bernie is that he wants immediate change over controversial & complicated issues, and although the majority of the country wants the progressive goals, the way Bernie wants to get there is not the most popular way – a smoother transition is what moderates desire.
There are other concerns surrounding Bernie’s health as he did have a heart attack at an earlier point in the race, but seeing as though every candidate left (excluding Tusli Gabbard) is in their 70s, it’s a boomer fight now – all of their health conditions are a concern.
Finally, the last concern: the Bernie Bros. I myself have been a victim of Bernie Bros toxicity as I am an avid Andrew Yang supporter, and it’s a legitimate concern. There are certain progressive supporters who don’t understand that you can’t win an election by bullying supporters of other candidates and then begging them to vote for their candidate. Project Veritas has gotten undercover videos of 4 separate paid campaign field organizers talking about how “Milwaukee will burn if he doesn’t get the nomination” and advocating that Stalin had the right idea with the gulags – they even said it might be necessary to “reeducate” Republicans using gulags. The Sanders’ campaign then proceeded to put all of their field organizers Twitter accounts on private and never acknowledged the videos. I don’t understand personally how someone who exemplifies every aspect of humanity can let his supporters spread such hate and toxicity, not only with the videos but on all social media. Anytime Andrew Yang tweets, there are hundreds of responses from Bernie supporters saying “Endorse Bernie” after literally months of harassment – Yang has already said he will support the Democratic nominee and would endorse anyone who supports UBI – but moral of the story, he’s still getting harassed constantly just for being nice to people who aren’t progressives.
This is the biggest issue and is why I think Bernie will not be able to unite the Democratic base. Moderates can’t vote for Bernie because they don’t agree with his policies (& actually might agree with Trump on certain policies), but progressives would be able to vote for Biden because they share some policy goals. Bernie’s campaign is built on anger and fighting against the establishment (similar to Trump), so giving the American people a chance to vote for something they believe in, ie. hope and the soul of the country, would produce a better result than anger and more division. Personally, I would support both of these candidates over Trump just because even though I don’t agree with Bernie’s methods, I love the heart he puts into what he does, and I love Biden’s message of “fighting for the soul of the country” because I truly think that’s what this election is. Yang was obviously my #1, but I would support both over Trump because I miss having a role model as president. Yes, Trump does cut through the normal shit inside politics, and he knows & embraces he’s a scumbag, but I don’t think having someone like Trump as president is good for the country. You don’t have to agree with the president on policy because there’s always going to be a political shift in office, but I still think we’re missing the peace and respect that presidents should have for not only the office, but all sides of the political spectrum. Trump, Biden, and Bernie don’t align with my policies exactly, but overall both Biden and Bernie align with my personal ideology of how politics should work.